Guides / Shopify discount code gives too much off sale items: why, and what to do

Shopify discount code gives too much off sale items: why, and what to do

By the MRP Discount team · Updated 11 November 2026

Short answer. A Shopify percentage code comes off the already reduced sale price, so the two discounts multiply: a 30% code on a product that is already 30% off makes it 51% off its original price. To stop it, keep sale items out of the code, or use a code that takes its % off the compare-at price so no product goes below the offer you advertised.

Why the discounts multiply

Take a product with an original price of $100, on sale at $70. A 30% code takes 30% off $70, which is $21, so the customer pays $49. Your banner said 30% off, and the product sold at 51% off.

Shopify isn't making a mistake here. Its discounts are built to work on the selling price, and the compare-at price is only for display. It just means a store with markdowns gives away more on every discounted order than the plan said.

Three ways to keep it in check

1. Keep sale items out of the code. Make a collection of full-price products and limit the code to it. Free and built into Shopify. Sale items then get no extra discount, and shoppers who wanted the code on a sale item may be disappointed. Steps: exclude sale items from a discount code.

2. Lower the code's % by hand. Pick a smaller % so the sale items don't go too deep. One % can't be right for products with different markdowns, so some products get too much and others too little.

3. Take the % off the compare-at price. With MRP Discount (our app), a 30% code takes 30% off the original price. The product on sale at $70 goes to $70 (it is already 30% off, so nothing extra), a product at $90 goes to $70, and a full-price product goes to $70. Everyone gets the 30% your banner promised.

  1. Install MRP Discount from the Shopify App Store.
  2. Open the app in your Shopify admin and choose Create discount.
  3. Type a code, such as FLAT30, and the percentage: 30%.
  4. Choose what it covers: all eligible products, chosen collections or chosen products. Add a minimum purchase, a usage limit, one use per customer or start and end dates if you want them.
  5. Save. The code also shows in Shopify's own Discounts page, next to your other codes.
  6. Test it: add one sale item to the cart, apply the code, and check the total is the compare-at price minus 30%.

How the options compare

Exclude sale itemsLower the % by handMRP Discount
Sale items getNothing extraDifferent amountsUp to the advertised %
Full-price items getThe full %Less than advertisedThe full %
UpkeepKeep the collection rightRedo the sums each saleNone
CostFreeFree$4.99 a month, 7 days free

Questions store owners ask

Why does my Shopify discount stack on items already on sale?

Because Shopify's codes take their % off the current selling price. If that price is already reduced, the code's % comes on top of the markdown.

Can I stop discount codes working on sale items in Shopify?

Yes. Limit the code to a collection that leaves out products with a compare-at price. Shopify has no single switch for it.

How much extra does stacking cost?

It depends on your markdowns. On a product already 30% off, a 30% code gives 21 points more off the original price than you planned (51% instead of 30%).

Will MRP Discount stack with my other codes?

No. Its codes don't combine with other discounts, so only one discount applies to the order.

Related answers

Run your next sale without touching a price.

Install it, make one code, and check it in your own checkout. The first 7 days are free.