Guides / Discount code or automatic discount: which one should your Shopify store use?

Discount code or automatic discount: which one should your Shopify store use?

Shopify gives you two ways to run a discount. One needs the shopper to type a code. The other applies by itself. Here is how to choose.

The short answer

Use a discount code when you want to control who gets the offer. Use an automatic discount when everyone who qualifies should get it, with no typing.

Both live under Discounts in your Shopify admin. Both can give a percentage off, a fixed amount off, or free shipping. The difference is how the shopper receives the offer.

How a discount code works

The shopper enters a code at checkout, for example DIWALI20. The discount applies only if the code is valid and the cart meets the rules you set.

Codes are good when you want to:

  • Send an offer to one group only, such as WhatsApp subscribers or email customers.
  • Give a creator or influencer their own code, so you can see which codes get used.
  • Run a private or early-access sale.
  • Limit the offer with usage limits, one use per customer, or start and end dates.

The weak point is the typing. Some shoppers forget the code, mistype it, or give up when it fails. If your ad or message does not make the code easy to copy, you lose orders.

How an automatic discount works

An automatic discount applies when the cart qualifies. The shopper does nothing. They see the lower price in the cart and at checkout.

Automatic discounts are good when you want to:

  • Run a sale for every visitor, such as a site-wide festive sale.
  • Reward bigger carts, such as a discount when the order crosses a set amount.
  • Remove the chance of a shopper missing the offer.

The weak point is control. Anyone who qualifies gets it, and you cannot hand it to one group only. Shopify also limits how many automatic discounts can be active at once, so check the current limit in the Shopify help centre before you plan a stack of them.

Side by side

  • Who gets it: a code goes to people you give it to. An automatic discount goes to everyone who qualifies.
  • Effort for the shopper: a code needs typing. An automatic discount needs nothing.
  • Tracking: a code shows you which channel or creator drove orders. An automatic discount gives you less detail about the source.
  • Best for: codes suit targeted offers. Automatic suits public sales.

A simple way to decide

  1. Is the offer for everyone? Choose automatic.
  2. Is it for one list, one creator or one campaign? Choose a code.
  3. Do you need to know where each order came from? Choose a code, one per channel.
  4. Is the shopper likely to be on a phone, in a hurry? Lean automatic, or give a code they can tap and copy.

Using both together

You can run both at once, but check the combination settings on each discount. Shopify lets you choose whether a discount can stack with other product, order or shipping discounts. If you leave stacking off, a shopper with a code may find the automatic discount disappears, or the other way round. That looks like a bug to them.

Before any sale, test the cart. Add a product, apply the code, and read the totals line by line. Do it on a phone too.

The MRP question

Indian stores often show an MRP (the compare-at price) next to a sale price. This adds one more thing to check. Shopify works the percentage out from the sale price, not the MRP. Say the MRP is Rs 1,000 and the product sells at Rs 800. A "Flat 40% off" discount takes 40% off Rs 800, so the shopper pays Rs 480. That is 52% below your MRP, far more than the 40% you meant to give.

This is true for codes and for automatic discounts. Whichever type you pick, run one test order and compare the final price with what your ad says. For the full picture, read MRP vs sale price: where your discount really comes from.

If you want a percentage code that calculates on the compare-at MRP, one option is the MRP Discount app. You create the code in the app, and it then shows in Shopify's Discounts page. Our guide on how to give a discount on MRP in Shopify walks through the options, including doing it by hand.

Common mistakes

  • Two offers that fight. A site-wide automatic discount plus a code with no stacking rule. Decide which wins and set it.
  • No end date. A festive code that is still live in January. Always set an end date.
  • A code nobody can read. Use short, clear codes in capitals. Avoid letters that look alike, such as O and 0.
  • No test. Placing one order yourself takes minutes and finds most problems.
  • One code for everything. If WhatsApp, email and creators all share one code, you cannot tell which worked. Give each its own.

Planning a festive sale?

For a sale with a clear start and end, many stores use an automatic discount for the public offer and separate codes for WhatsApp, email and creators. That gives everyone a simple price and still lets you track each channel. See how to run a Diwali sale on MRP in Shopify for a step-by-step plan.

Quick checklist

  1. Pick code or automatic based on who should get the offer.
  2. Set the start date, end date and any usage limit.
  3. Check the stacking settings.
  4. Confirm what the percentage is calculated on: MRP or sale price.
  5. Place a test order on desktop and phone.
  6. Write the offer in your ad exactly as the checkout will show it.

More guides

Run your next sale on the MRP.

Install it, make one code, and check it in your own checkout. The first 7 days are free.